Click here for printer-friendly version.


Curriculum Connections

Garden Investigations: Testing Partnerships
If you focus on growing garden companions, you'll have lots of opportunities to engage your students in authentic science. After all, many of the companion planting strategies in practice are based on historical observations or beliefs about which plants help each other grow better, rather than on strict scientific research. And each garden system is unique. Student teams might plant selected companions and chart plant growth, insect visitors, or other factors over time, or they might set up some controlled experiments. Their research questions might be inspired by companion planting traditions (many of which are featured in this newsletter); their own garden observations; or what they've learned about plant needs from seed catalogs, books, or the Internet. Here are some sample questions:

  • If we surround a bed with garlic, will it have fewer pests than one that has no garlic around it?
  • Will we get a bigger corn harvest if we grow pole beans between corn rows? (Note: Give the corn a head start of a few weeks.)
  • Will flea beetles bother radishes in our vegetable plot rather than attack our cabbage seedlings?
  • Can we get bigger pumpkins if we grow clover between the hills?
  • If we put plants that are supposed to attract beneficial insects in one section of our schoolyard, will we find more of the "good guys" there than in other parts of the campus?
  • Will spinach planted in the shade of peas last longer than spinach planted in an open bed?
  • How can we arrange lettuce and onions in a plot to get the best yield?
As groups plan investigations, help them consider the "steps" they'll take in terms that help them think through the problem. Some of the questions to ponder throughout the process are: What do we want to find out about? How can we make the best observations? What do we already think we know or have we observed about ____? What is the best way to answer our questions? What types of data will we need? How can we make it a "fair" test? What types of observations or measurements should we take? How can we organize and communicate the data and results to present the clearest answer or strongest explanation? They can then mirror what scientists do by presenting their plans to peers, who give feedback on the experimental setups.


Plant Family Detectives
Before you tackle companion planting, think about having your students dig into plant families. Plants that are closely related often have similar nutrient needs, attract or repel the same types of insects, are susceptible to similar diseases, and so on. Learning about these kinship ties can inspire close observations and help students make planting decisions.

Flower structure is the main criterion scientists use for grouping plants into families. For instance, legumes, such as peas and beans, have irregular flowers with a top and bottom petal surrounded by wing-like petals (photo is of sweetpea flower). Cabbage family plants, including broccoli, kale, mustard, turnips, and radishes, have four flower petals arranged in a cross shape. Plants in both families have pod-like fruits. (Other criteria for grouping plants into families include seed and fruit numbers and types.) Although botanists have named about 300 plant families, a handful of enormous families represent many of our garden denizens. These include the mint, mustard (cabbage), parsley (carrot), lily (onion), rose, pea, daisy (aster), and grass families. The potato family, solanaceae, features such garden favorites as tomatoes, peppers, and eggplant, as well as highly toxic plants, such as deadly nightshade. Although the flower structure is usually telltale, the average size of different plant species in each family can vary greatly; apple trees, for instance, are in the rose family.

Invite your students to use their eyes and hand lenses to closely observe a variety of flowers in the neighborhood, schoolyard, and garden. They should look at and describe or draw each flower as a whole and then take a closeup view. Have them examine the number and nature of different flower parts (e.g., stamens). Ask individuals or small groups to identify three flowers they think are closely related and use clues (evidence) from their observations to support their choices. Ask, How do your ideas (inferences) compare with those of other students? Which similarities were most dramatic?

Once students have done their own detective work, they can use the Internet, books, or field guides to check hunches and extend their understanding. (Plant Families, a book by Carol Lerner, is an excellent resource for upper elementary students. It is out of print, so check for it at a local library.) Here are some other family-related activity suggestions:

  • Research the Latin names of plant families. What do they tell you about the flower or plant? For instance, the Latin name of the mustard/cabbage family, Cruciferae, means "cross-bearers" (see photo, right). The carrot family name, Umbelliferae, is descriptive because the flower head is curved up like an inside-out umbrella.
  • Examine different plants in the mint family, such as spearmint, basil, and oregano. Try to guess which feature, besides flower structure, most plants in this family share. (In cross section, the stems are square. Students can feel this by rolling a stem between their fingers.)
  • Design a wall chart of common plant families found around the school. Press plants or post drawings or photographs along with descriptions of each family.

Design an Edible Landscape
Invite your students to see vegetables and herbs through a new lens as they muse about a garden, schoolyard, or even one bed that uses food plants artistically. They might start simply, by choosing a few vegetable or herb plants to place into existing flower beds or incorporate into new ones. (Have them think about mature heights when making decisions about what to plant where.) A more involved project could include perusing vegetable and flower gardens, seed catalogs and packets, and other resources, and thinking about colors, textures, sizes, and forms. The class can then use these resources, along with advice from neighborhood gardeners, to begin to figure out planting schemes and calendars and draft maps for different areas.

Imagine the possibilities for practicing teamwork and honing math and art skills as students puzzle out design details. How much space does a bean tepee take up? How closely can we plant lettuce and parsley? What do we have to plant and when should we plant it in order to have great colors throughout the season?


Copyright© 2003
National Gardening Association

 


Contents

Pg. 1: Growing
Garden Companions

Background

Growing Garden Companions

Finding Compatible Needs

Perplexing Pests

Creating Artistic Edible
Landscapes



Pg. 2: Curriculum Connections

Garden Investigations


Plant Family Detectives

Design an Edible Landscape


Pg. 3: Resources

Web Sites We Like

Books


Related Articles

Cross-grade Buddies Plant Companions

Organic Matters

Pest Patrol

Peas, Beans, and Bacteria

The Three Sisters: Native American Gardening


Designing Gardens?

Garden Mosaics is filled with actual school garden plans, stories of how students participated in the design process, how-to information, and resources.
You'll find details in our Gardening with Kids Store.